Top Rated Restaurants Near Shelter Island

287 NY-25A , Rocky Point NY

32.78 miles

271 Grand Ave , New Haven CT

33.50 miles

56 Main Street Annex , New Haven CT

32.49 miles

2133 Middle Country Rd , Centereach NY

41.64 miles

430 Main St , Center Moriches NY

30.17 miles

810 Middle Country Rd , Selden NY

39.24 miles

361 Liberty St. , Meriden CT

39.69 miles

151 Queen Street , Southington CT

47.15 miles

92 Quinnipiac St , Wallingford CT

36.89 miles

405 Main St , East Haven CT

31.63 miles

175 Middle Country Road , Middle Island NY

35.42 miles

338 Bridgeport Ave , Milford CT

40.57 miles